Literature Search, Rapid Critical Appraisal, and Summary
PICOT QUESTION: Advantages of Breast Feeding for a Newborn Baby
For this assignment, you will locate two research studies related to the topic and PICOT questions that you developed in Week 2. The articles must be current (within the last five years), and one article must be quantitative, and one article must be qualitative.
Article choice is very important, therefore:
Articles used for this assignment cannot be used for the other assignments. The selected articles should be original research studies. Review articles, concept analysis, meta-analysis, meta-synthesis, integrative review, and systemic review articles should not be used.
Mixed-methods studies should not be used.
There are two parts to this assignment.
Part 1: Complete a Rapid Critical Appraisal Checklist
Select one each: qualitative and quantitative research articles.
Create a Rapid Critical Appraisal Checklist for the tworesearch articles (one column per article).
Complete withbrief,concise, summarized information.
Part II: Write a summary (one- to two- pages)
Identify differences between quantitative and qualitative designs and research methods.
Use current APA Style for your summary paper and to cite your sources.
Submit the checklist andsummary.
9/28/2020 R D a NURS 350 R a N 202008FAI OL-A
:// a . a . / a / / / / a R ? = & P = & C =1& =_3691227_1& _ =_60547_1 1/5
R b c D a
A b ic li g adi g c i e ia ha i c e e al a e de k. Y i c li ked a b ic hi i e
a d ade i a ailable . Selec Grid Vie Li Vie cha ge he b ic’ la .
Mee
E ceed
E ec a i
M
Mee
E ec a i
Be
E ec a i
D e N
Mee
E ec a i
T b a i e e ea ch
a ic e
( e a i a i e a d e
a i a i e) a e c ea
ide i ed a igi a
e ea ch die .
9 (4.50%) – 10
(5.00%)
T a ,
b a
a c (
a a
a d
a a )
a c d
a d a
ab
a
a c
d .
7.6 (3.80%) –
8.9 (4.45%)
T a c
(
a a
a d
a a )
a c d
a d a
b a ,
b a a
a
ab
a
a c
d ,
c
b a .
6 (3.00%) – 7.5
(3.75%)
O a c
c d a d
d d a
a a
a a
a c ,
a
ab
a
a c
d .
0 (0.00%) –
(2.95%)
A c a
a
a c ;
a a
a d
a a
a c a
d d.
De c i i f he e ea ch
b e a d e f
36 (18.00%) –
40 (20.00%)
30.4 (15.20%) –
35.6 (17.80%)
24 (12.00%) –
30 (15.00%)
0 (0.00%) –
23.6 (11.80
Na : NURS350-Li e a e Re ie i h Ra id C i ica A ai a Check i
E
G id Vie L V
9/28/2020 R D a NURS 350 R a N 202008FAI OL-A
:// a . a . / a / / / / a R ? = & P = & C =1& =_3691227_1& _ =_60547_1 2/5
Mee
E ceed
E ec a i
M
Mee
E ec a i
Be
E ec a i
D e N
Mee
E ec a i
each e ea ch a ic e The e ea ch
blem and
he e
f each
a icle a e
e e l
e amined.
The e ea ch
blem and
he e
f each
a icle a e
ade a el
e amined
i h min
mi i n
e .
The e ea ch
blem and
he e
f each
a icle a e
ag e, ab en
n
iden i ed,
and c n ain
maj
mi i n
e .
The e ea
blem a
i
a e n
iden i ed f
an f he
a icle .
De c i i f he e ea ch
e h d f each e ea ch
a ic e
27 (13.50%) –
30 (15.00%)
An e en i e
de c i i n f
he a iable ,
he am le,
and he
e ea ch
me h d i
clea l
e en ed f
each a icle.
22.8 (11.40%) –
26.7 (13.35%)
An ade a e
de c i i n f
he, a iable ,
he am le,
and he
e ea ch
me h d i
e en ed f
m a icle
i h min
mi i n
e .
18 (9.00%) –
22.5 (11.25%)
An
n a i fac
de c i i n f
he a iable ,
am le, and
he e ea ch
me h d i
e en ed f
b h a icle
i h maj
mi i n
e .
0 (0.00%) –
17.7 (8.85%
A de c i
f he
a iable ,
am le, an
he e ea
me h d i
n
e en ed
an f he
a icle .
S a f he
di g /c c i / he e
36 (18.00%) –
40 (20.00%)
30.4 (15.20%) –
35.6 (17.80%)
24 (12.00%) –
30 (15.00%)
0 (0.00%) –
23.6 (11.80
9/28/2020 R D a NURS 350 R a N 202008FAI OL-A
:// a . a . / a / / / / a R ? = & P = & C =1& =_3691227_1& _ =_60547_1 3/5
Mee
E ceed
E ec a i
M
Mee
E ec a i
Be
E ec a i
D e N
Mee
E ec a i
g
f each e ea ch a ic e A e e l
e ami ed
i e iga i
f he
di g ,
heme , a d
c cl i
f b h
a icle i
killf ll
e e ed f
each a icle.
A ade a e
i e iga i
f he
di g ,
heme , a d
c cl i
f b h i
a i fac il
e e ed
i h mi
mi i
e .
A
a i fac
i e iga i
f he
di g ,
heme , a d
c cl i
f b h
a icle i
ided i h
maj
mi i
e , l
e f he
a icle i
i e iga ed
a d
e e ed
a i fac il .
A de c i
f he
di g ,
heme , a
c cl i
i
e e ed
ei he a ic
De c i i f he
i i a i ie a d di e e ce
a g he e ea ch a ic e
54 (27.00%) –
60 (30.00%)
The
de c i i f
he
imila i ie
a d
di e e ce
am g he
e ea ch
a icle i
clea a d
h gh.
45.6 (22.80%) –
53.4 (26.70%)
The
de c i i f
he
imila i ie
a d
di e e ce
am g he
e ea ch
a icle i
ade a e
i h mi
mi i
e .
36 (18.00%) –
45 (22.50%)
The
de c i i f
he
imila i ie
a d
di e e ce
am g he
e ea ch
a icle i
i ade a e
i h maj
mi i
e .
0 (0.00%) –
35.4 (17.70
The
de c i i
he
imila i ie
a d
di e e ce
am g he
e ea ch
a icle i
ided.
APA 9 (4.50%) – 10
(5.00%)
7.6 (3.80%) –
8.9 (4.45%)
6 (3.00%) – 7.5
(3.75%)
0 (0.00%) –
(2.95%)
9/28/2020 R D a NURS 350 R a N 202008FAI OL-A
:// a . a . / a / / / / a R ? = & P = & C =1& =_3691227_1& _ =_60547_1 4/5
Mee o
E ceed
E pec a ion
Mo l
Mee
E pec a ion
Belo
E pec a ion
Doe No
Mee
E pec a i
U e APA
S e
acc a e
a d
c e
c e
ce h
1 2
e .
S ce a e
e e c ed
a d a e ee –
e e ed,
e e a
ce .
Mee a
f a g
e e e
( e g h a d
e) f he
a g e .
U e APA
S e h
c a
a
h 3 4
e .
S ce a e
e ha
e e a , b
a be
ed
ch a
a e. Mee
f a g
e e e
( e g h a d
e) f he
a g e .
Re ec
c e e
edge f
APA S e h
5 6 e .
S ce a e
c ed,
he e a e
a e .
S ce a e
ch a
a e.
Mee
f a g
e e e
( e g h a d
e) f he
a g e .
D e
APA S e,
he e a e
e a e
e
h gh
he a e .
D e
ee
f a g
e e e
( e g h a
e) f h
a g e
Mechanic 9 (4.50%) – 10
(5.00%)
7.6 (3.80%) –
8.9 (4.45%)
6 (3.00%) – 7.5
(3.75%)
0 (0.00%) –
(2.95%)
9/28/2020 R D a NURS 350 R a N 202008FAI OL-A
:// a . a . / a / / / / a R ? = & P = & C =1& =_3691227_1& _ =_60547_1 5/5
Meets or
E ceeds
E pectations
Mostl
Meets
E pectations
Belo
E pectations
Does Not
Meet
E pectati
The writing
demonstrates
a
sophisticated
clarity,
conciseness,
and
correctness;
includes
thorough
details and
information;
and is
extremely
well
organi ed.
Punctuation,
spelling, and
capitali ation
are all
correct. There
are minimal
to no errors.
The writing is
accomplished
in terms of
clarity and
conciseness,
includes
su cient
details, and is
well
organi ed,
but it may
contain a few
errors.
Punctuation,
spelling, and
capitali ation
are generally
correct with
not many
errors.
The writing
lacks clarity or
conciseness,
contains
numerous
errors, and
lacks
organi ation.
Errors in
punctuation,
spelling, and
capitali ation
detract from
the
readability of
the paper
The writing
unfocused
rambling,
contains
serious
errors; lac
detail and
relevant d
and
informatio
and is poo
organi ed
There are
many
distracting
errors in
punctuatio
spelling, a
capitali at
Name:NURS350-Literature Revie ith Rapid Critical Appraisal Checklists
Exit
