Discussion
Please watch this video and visit the ACLU website. Discuss with your classmates your thoughts on whethercitizens should be able to audio/video record police officers in public? How have police departments changed to compact the unfriendly videos snippets often posted online?How do you think the recent protests will impact the issue of citizen video taping and police officer body cameras?
Skip to main content
1-855-435-7693
Call ICIRR’s hotline for emergency immigration assistance
Know your rights if stopped by ICE
Find out more
ACLU of Illinois
About
About Us
Contact Us
Job Openings
Staff
Board of Directors
Next Generation Society
Chapters
Alex McCray Scholarship
Request ACLU Speaker
Issues
All Issues
LGBTQ and HIV Advocacy
Women’s and Reproductive Rights
Criminal Justice Reform
First Amendment Advocacy
Police Practices and Racial Justice
Voting Rights
Our Work
Campaigns
Cases
Legislation
News
All News
Transgender Prisoner in Federal Custody Asks Court to Order Adequate Health Care and Ensure Her Safety
Its Time to Stop the Cycle of Discrimination Against Pregnant Workers
ACLU of Illinois Testimony on Police Training and Use of Force
Press Releases
Publications
Talking Liberties
Act
Events
Legal Help
Request Legal Assistance
Know Your Rights
Donate
Support Our Work
Become a Member
Give a Gift in Honor or Memory of
Give a Gift Membership
Recurring Donations
Join the Next Generation Society
Make a Legacy Gift
Donate Appreciated Stock
About Your Donation
Donate
Support Our Work
Become a Member
Give a Gift in Honor or Memory of
Give a Gift Membership
Recurring Donations
Join the Next Generation Society
Make a Legacy Gift
Donate Appreciated Stock
About Your Donation
ACLU v. Alvarez
In August 2010, we sued the Cook County States Attorney, Anita Alvarez, seeking to enjoin prosecution of the ACLU under the Illinois Eavesdropping Act for expanding our police monitoring program to include audio recording of on-duty police in public places. The case arose from a number of instances in which individuals or organizations that wanted to monitor police activity in order to detect any misconduct were prosecuted under the law. The ACLU itself was the plaintiff in this case because we frequently monitor police behavior and wanted to make audio recordings of police performing their public duties. We asserted that the ACLU has a First Amendment right to gather this information, disseminate it to the public, and present it to courts and government agencies in petitioning for redress of grievances.
In January 2011, U.S. District Court Judge Susan Conlon denied our motion for a preliminary injunction and dismissed the lawsuit, ruling that there was no First Amendment right to record an on-duty police officer operating in public. We appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit. The Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press and six other media organizations joined as amicus on our behalf.
In May 2012, the appellate court ruled in our favor, finding that the First Amendment protects the ACLU program. The court ordered the trial court to enter a preliminary injunction in our favor. In July 2012, the federal district court issued the preliminary injunction, but also granted the States Attorneys request to stay proceedings while they sought review of the Appeals Courts decision by the Supreme Court of the United States. In November 2012, the Supreme Court denied the defendants request for review. In December 2012, the federal district court granted our unopposed motion for summary judgment, and in January 2013 issued the permanent injunction that we sought.
In a later case, the Illinois Eavesdropping Act was also struck down by the Illinois Supreme Court. (People v. Melongo, 2014 IL 114852.) The current version of the statute, enacted in 014, only prohibits recording of private conversations. There is currently no prohibition of recording police officers in public in Illinois.
Attorney(s)
Harvey Grossman, Adam Schwartz, Karen Sheley
Date filed
August 19, 2010
Court
U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois; U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit
Judge
Judge Susan Conlon; Judge Sharon Johnson Coleman; Judge Richard Posner; Judge Diane Sykes; Judge David Hamilton
Status
Won appeal
Case number
10-CV-05235
Stay informed
Email address *
Zip code *
Leave this field blank
Related Issues
First Amendment Advocacy
Police Practices and Racial Justice
Documents
pdfOriginal Complaint.pdf
pdfMemorandum in Support of Plaintiff’s Motion for a Preliminary Injunction.pdf
pdfCombined Rely in Support of Motion for Preliminary Injunction and Response in Opposition to Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss.pdf
pdfACLU’s Memorandum in Support of It’s Motion to Amend Judgment, the File an Amended Complaint, and for a Preliminary Injunction.pdf
pdfACLU’s Motion to Amend Judgment, to File an Amended Complaint, and for a Preliminary Injunction.pdf
pdfAmended Complaint.pdf
pdfConnell Declaration.pdf
pdfCarter Declaration.pdf
pdfAppellants Brief.pdf
pdfAppellants Reply Brief.pdf
pdfAppellate Courts Ruling.pdf
pdfDistrict Courts Opinion Granting Summary Judgment.pdf
pdfDistrict Court’s Permanent Injunction.pdf
Related Stories
New brief filed in ACLU v. Alvarez
October 7, 2010
ACLU seeks end to prosecutions for recording public conversations…
August 19, 2010
ACLU amends challenge to eavesdropping law
November 19, 2010
Appeal Filed in ACLU v. Alvarez
April 20, 2011
Chicago Tribune: Woman who recorded cops acquitted of felony…
August 26, 2011
Chicago Sun-Times Editorial: Protect the publics right to eavesdrop
August 29, 2011
ACLU asks appeals court to prevent future prosecutions for…
September 13, 2011
Audio from Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals Hearing
September 14, 2011
ABC 7: ACLU challenges Ill. Eavesdropping Act in court
September 14, 2011
Huffington Post: Illinois Eavesdropping Law Supported By…
September 14, 2011
Thanks to citizens with cameras
November 29, 2011
WTTW: Eavesdropping Law
December 16, 2011
Chicago Tribune: State’s eavesdropping law faces growing challenges
January 3, 2012
Slate: Recording Police Making Arrests & the Outrageous Law that…
February 2, 2012
Chicago Tribune: Police back bill allowing them to record drug…
April 2, 2012
Chicago Tribune: Chicago police won’t enforce eavesdropping law…
May 2, 2012
Victory for First Amendment Right to Audio Record Police
May 8, 2012
Chicago Tribune: Court orders ban on enforcement of Illinois…
May 9, 2012
Court issues order barring controversial enforcement of Illinois’…
July 9, 2012
Final Judgment and Permanent Injunction Issued in Eavesdropping Case
December 21, 2012
Journal-Courier: ACLU asks if Morgan Co. would prosecute recording…
August 13, 2013
The Courthouse News Service: Illinois Eavesdropping Law Assailed on…
January 15, 2014
The Columbia Chronicle: Controversial eavesdropping law struck down
April 8, 2014
WUIS: Lawmakers Work To Replace Illinois Eavesdropping Law
June 19, 2014
Search aclu-il.org
Press
Legal Help
Careers
Donate
ACLU on Facebook
ACLU on Twitter
ACLU on YouTube
2020 ACLU of Illinois
User Agreement
Privacy Statement
Website Accessibility
